Grandma's Tales

November 27, 2006

Munnabhai and Gandhigiri

Filed under: Language — Geeta Padmanabhan @ 10:28 pm

I finally got to watch Lageraho Munnabhai. The DVD had good picture quality but kept freezing from time to time, so as a movie experience it wasn’t much. But the movie has its points. It proves, if proof were needed, it’s the supporting cast that gives a movie – especially one that is anecdotal – its edge.

Years ago, I attended a theatre workshop in Calcutta (that’s what it was then) conducted by Shombu Mitra. I’ve forgotten the details but a couple of things he said about characterisation stuck with me. “It’s not the appearance, the costume or the props that makes you see a character as a king. It’s the way his subject walks in, bows and speaks with reverence that establishes his authority.”

It’s the same with Munnabhai. We knew, more or less, what Sanjay and Arshad were going to do. They would be predictably good. But this movie is not about the lead actors. It’s about the small incidents that get resolved through Gandhigiri. It’s about these sub-plots that, like side dishes for a plate of rice, add flavour and give strength to the narrative. They give substance to the theme and prove the filmmaker’s argument that Gandhigiri works.

And wisely, the director lavishes care on the actors doing cameo roles in the mini plots. Take the spitting incident for instance. The guy with a bucket and towel starts by showing helpless anger, which turns to revulsion at what he’s bidden to do. He sports a phoney smile every time he cleans up after the big guy and finally, when the turnaround occurs displays genuine happiness. Voila! What a performance!

So is it with the guy who’s forced to confess to dad that he’s lost a lot of money. And Lucky, except when he tends to go a bit overboard is superb too. These are the people who make it all so believable. Yes, they did that. Or why did people try those methods in their attempts for justice?

Will Gandhigiri work? I asked my husband, an ex government officer. He laughed so much I thought he might have an attack or something. “But it worked for that pensioner who starts stripping!” I said when he stopped to catch his breath. He laughed again, but finally conceded, “Yeah, it might, mind you, just might, in one in a thousand cases. Even here, it has to be one-on-one and the guy who’s applying Gandhigiri should be a monument of patience.” He paused and asked with narrowed eyes, “Are you planning to try it on me?”

Coincidentally, I also watched Catch Me If You Can this week-end. In this movie, DiCaprio, a teenager, passes himself off as an airline pilot, a Harvard-educated doctor and finally as a lawyer. He does it all with his wits (and an extra-ordinary eye for detail) alone; there’s no side-kick to organise things for him. The first two covers are blown, but the third one manages to stay tight. DiCaprio retains his lawyer identity. How, how? The obsessed FBI agent Hanratty (Tom Hanks) wants to know. He promises the boy that he would find out somehow. He doesn’t. You would never guess the answer. Hanratty is the chaser, the admirer and in the end, the Father figure the boy so desperately needs.

Again, will Gandhigiri work? Just read this:

Justin Wurth, 18, Duane Barry, 19, and Tyler Pearce, 19, have been accused of breaking into a small US church just before midnight Nov. 12. Police said they stole money and electronic equipment, smashed windows and computer monitors and sprayed a fire extinguisher in the church gym. The youngsters are accused of taking away several hundred dollars worth of gift cards, Xboxes and controllers, a DVD and a VCR players.

Members of the church have decided to punish the three teenagers with love. They are putting together “love baskets” full of electronic items for each one of the suspects. “We’ve also made mistakes,” said the pastor. “But god forgives us.”

Will this gesture help to keep the kids off crime? Make a guess.



  1. Geetaji, wonderful!!! This is a real surprise 🙂 you writing about a film, but this film deserve to be written by someone like you. Is the DVD out?

    Comment by Paresh — November 28, 2006 @ 10:22 pm | Reply

  2. Thanks Rajesh. In my TWWI days, I had to train tutors to teach students how to write reviews. We made an exhaustive list of things to look for in a movie!But when you have a movie with a hackneyed plot, no acting to speak of, and the regulation song-dance-court-room-kidnap-juduva bhai routine, I’m quite befuddled and find it difficult to analyse it. My comments might consist of just a word or two. But Munnabhai was different, wasn’t it? Yes, the DVD is available (I don’t know if it’s out!). I rented it at the shop on the main road. BTW, did you guess how the “lawyer” cover stayed intact?

    Comment by Geeta Padmanabhan — November 29, 2006 @ 8:19 pm | Reply

  3. i feel that rang de’s ideas of force will be more successful
    after all ang de goes to the oscars not munnabhai, so the public still are more into bhagat singhs methods than gandhijis

    Comment by Varun Chablani — November 29, 2006 @ 9:11 pm | Reply

  4. Buddy it was me Paresh – who made the first comment, not Rajesh, who addresses you as Geetaji. 🙂 I was just checking what kind of Gandhigiri you’d use on me for calling you Geetaji :d. But you deserve a Jadoo Ki Jhappi (from the first installment of Munnabhai) for this mixup.:)

    I haven’t seen ‘Catch Me If You Can’, so cannot comment on that.

    Comment by Paresh — November 29, 2006 @ 10:30 pm | Reply

  5. Absolutely, Varun. I also have this theory that we, as a nation, are incapable of laughing at ourselves. We are a tad too serious.

    Comment by Geeta Padmanabhan — November 29, 2006 @ 10:34 pm | Reply

  6. You caught me there, Paresh. I shall rap my knuckles with a piece of cooked spaghetti for reading your name wrong. Will also learn to wipe my glasses.
    You really don’t have to watch the movie to make that guess. How can you pass yourself off as a lawyer without that cover ever blowing off?

    Comment by Geeta Padmanabhan — November 29, 2006 @ 10:39 pm | Reply

RSS feed for comments on this post. TrackBack URI

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

Create a free website or blog at

%d bloggers like this: